Have you ever wondered why millions of people continue to support controversial leaders despite overwhelming criticism? It’s a puzzle that has baffled social scientists, psychologists, and philosophers alike. With the political climate in 2025 more polarized than ever, understanding the roots of this loyalty is crucial—not just for politics but for our emotional and social wellbeing.
Recently, an illuminating piece in The Atlantic titled “Why Do So Many People Think That Trump Is Good?” delves deeply into this question, using the work of moral philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre as a lens to understand this phenomenon. MacIntyre’s ideas offer a powerful framework to unpack the values and narratives that sustain unwavering support for figures like Donald Trump.
So, what does MacIntyre tell us about moral communities and shared values?
MacIntyre argues that people belong to communities that share specific moral traditions and practices. These communities shape how individuals judge what is ‘good’ or ‘right.’ When people encounter leaders who articulate and reinforce their community’s values and identity, they often see those leaders as good, trustworthy, and worthy of support—even if outsiders perceive these leaders very differently.
This means, for many Trump supporters, their allegiance isn’t just political, it’s deeply moral and identity-based. The controversies don’t necessarily diminish their perception of him; instead, they may even strengthen their resolve.
Why does this matter for your emotional wellness?
Understanding this dynamic can help us navigate conversations across divides with more empathy and patience. When we see support for controversial figures as more than mere politics—viewing it instead as a reflection of community and identity—we open up pathways for dialogue that honor emotions and values rather than dismissing them outright.
But here’s the twist: This phenomenon isn't isolated to politics; it mirrors how people approach deeply personal and sensitive areas of life—including fertility journeys.
Many individuals and couples face sensitivities and intimate challenges, whether due to physical conditions, emotional stress, or societal pressures. Just like political allegiances, their approach to fertility solutions is guided by trust, moral comfort, and the values that feel right and safe for them.
For example, at-home fertility options that respect users’ privacy, comfort, and unique sensitivities have become increasingly sought after. This is where companies like MakeAMom shine, offering reusable insemination kits that are not only discreet and cost-effective but also thoughtfully designed for people with specific sensitivities or conditions.
If you’ve found standard clinical fertility methods intimidating or alienating, an at-home system that aligns with your values and comfort level can be a game-changer. It’s no coincidence that MakeAMom reports a 67% average success rate, reflecting both the efficacy and the emotional reassurance their kits provide.
Interested in exploring how technology can empower you sensitively and confidently? Check out this at-home intracervical insemination syringe kit tailored for fertility support that honors privacy and personal care.
Back to the big picture: The moral philosopher’s insights remind us that human beings are wired to seek belonging and meaning. Whether it’s unwavering political support or the choices we make on our fertility journeys, the principles remain strikingly similar.
So, how do you harness this understanding in your life?
- Reflect on what core values and communities influence your decisions.
- Practice empathy when encountering views or choices that differ from your own.
- Seek solutions—whether political dialogue or personal fertility methods—that align with your authentic self.
In a world brimming with division and sensitivity, this nuanced perspective is more than academic—it’s a practical guide to fostering connection and wellness.
What do you think? Have you experienced the power of shared values shaping your life decisions? Share your stories or questions below—we’d love to hear from you!