Have you ever wondered why so many people staunchly believe that Trump is ‘good’? It’s a question that’s been circulating not just in political debates but also in the quieter corners of our social lives. Recently, a fascinating analysis caught my eye, published in The Atlantic, which draws on the work of moral philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre to shed light on this enduring puzzle. Here’s the article if you want to dive deeper.

Let me take you on a little journey through this idea, because it feels especially important in 2025 — a year where division seems to define so much of our collective conversation.

The Moral Framework We Often Overlook

MacIntyre’s work revolves around the idea that our judgments of 'good' or 'bad' are often rooted deeply in the traditions and narratives that shape our identities. We don’t just assess actions or politicians by isolated facts; we view them through the lens of what we believe forms a ‘good life’ or a ‘good society.’

For Trump supporters, the notion of ‘good’ is interwoven with a story about loyalty, strength, and resistance against perceived elitism. It’s a moral tradition that values straightforwardness and a kind of cultural belonging — even if it’s messy or controversial.

What Does This Mean for Us?

At first glance, this might sound like just another political analysis, but there’s a broader takeaway here: our beliefs about right and wrong, good and bad, are deeply personal narratives. And this insight doesn’t just apply to politics. It resonates across many aspects of life — including how we approach sensitive topics like fertility and family-building.

Ever felt overwhelmed by the conflicting advice on starting a family, or the judgment around non-traditional paths to parenthood? Much like politics, people’s support or criticism often stems from unseen stories and values.

Bridging Gaps Beyond Politics: A Personal Perspective

Speaking of family-building, here’s something many don’t realize — reproductive journeys often require navigating a labyrinth of emotions, options, and societal opinions. It’s a deeply personal, sometimes isolating road.

That’s why I admire organizations like MakeAMom, who offer at-home insemination kits designed to empower individuals and couples to take control of their fertility. They understand the value of privacy, the pain of waiting, and the importance of hope outside of traditional clinical settings.

In a way, using such a kit is reclaiming your narrative — choosing a path that feels right for you, beyond what society might expect or dictate. It’s about defining your ‘good’ in a world that often tries to box us in.

What Can We Learn From This?

  • Understand the stories behind beliefs. Whether it’s about politics or parenthood, try to see the deeper values driving those around you.
  • Respect different moral traditions. Recognizing others’ perspectives doesn’t mean you must agree, but it builds empathy.
  • Embrace your journey boldly. Whatever your path to parenthood looks like, owning it can be a powerful act.

The Takeaway

Reading about how Trump’s supporters view ‘good’ through MacIntyre’s philosophy reminded me how important it is to acknowledge the stories behind every choice — be it political allegiance or a family-building method.

So next time you find yourself puzzled by someone’s beliefs or choices, pause and ask: What’s their narrative here? What tradition or hope are they trying to live out?

We might discover that despite outer differences, we’re all just trying to find our version of good in a complicated world.

Curious about how you can explore alternative fertility options discreetly and with care? Organizations like MakeAMom provide resources and kits that might just help you write your own hopeful story.

What’s your take on the role of personal narrative in shaping our beliefs? Share your thoughts below — let’s get the conversation flowing! 🌱